401(k)
IRA
Taxable Brokerage

401k vs IRA vs Taxable Account Comparison

Compare different investment account types to maximize your retirement savings and minimize taxes.

Recommendation: 401(k)

Based on after-tax value, choosing 401(k) saves you $44,068.00 compared to other options.

Your Numbers

$

Amount invested each month

Best

401(k)

Employer-sponsored, possible match, higher limits

Final Balance

—

Highest

After-Tax Value

$302,704.00

Highest
Tax Savings Now—★
Withdrawal Flexibility—

IRA

Individual account, more investment choices

Final Balance

—

After-Tax Value

$258,636.00

Tax Savings Now—
Withdrawal Flexibility—

Taxable Brokerage

No contribution limits, capital gains taxes

Final Balance

—

After-Tax Value

$258,636.00

Tax Savings Now—
Withdrawal Flexibility—

Detailed Comparison

Metric401(k)IRATaxable Brokerage
Final Balance———
After-Tax Value$302,704.00$258,636.00$258,636.00
Tax Savings Now———
Withdrawal Flexibility———

Related Calculators

Understanding Your Options

401(k)

Employer-sponsored, possible match, higher limits

IRA

Individual account, more investment choices

Taxable Brokerage

No contribution limits, capital gains taxes